Which Peanut Butter Is Right for You? A Complete Guide to Every Type

Which Peanut Butter Is Right for You? A Complete Guide to Every Type

Walk into any grocery store today and you'll notice something interesting. Peanut butter is no longer just peanut butter.

There are so many variations - smooth, crunchy, clean, chocolate, high-protein and even crispy variations. We know it can get a little confusing. 

Well, the good news? 

There's probably a MyFitness Peanut Butter made specifically to suit your diet. 

If You Like the Classics

Sometimes, simple is best.

MyFitness Original Peanut Butter Smooth is for people who want a creamy, easy-to-spread option for toast, sandwiches, smoothies, or oats. With 28g protein per 100g and 95% less oil separation, it delivers consistency in every spoonful.

Prefer a little texture? MyFitness Original Peanut Butter Crunchy offers the same protein-rich goodness with crunchy peanut pieces in every bite. It's perfect for people who enjoy a bit of crunch in their breakfast.

If You Want Nothing But Peanuts

MyFitness Natural Unsweetened Peanut Butter Smooth and MyFitness Natural Unsweetened Peanut Butter Crunchy contain just one ingredient: roasted peanuts.

No added sugar. No added ingredients. Just peanuts.

They're also keto-friendly, vegan, and gluten-free, making them a popular choice for people following specific dietary preferences.

If You're Cutting Back on Sugar

Trying to reduce added sugar doesn't mean you have to give up peanut butter.

The MyFitness Zero Added Sugar Peanut Butter Crunchy delivers 28g protein per 100g while keeping the sweetness out of the equation. It's extra crunchy, satisfying, and a great option for people who want a more controlled approach to their nutrition.

If You Believe Chocolate Makes Everything Better

Let's be honest. Many of us don't need much convincing when chocolate is involved.

Chocolate Smooth, Chocolate Crunchy, Chocolate Crispy, and Chocolate Almond Crunch combine roasted peanuts with rich chocolate flavour for a more indulgent experience.

The Chocolate Crispy variant adds rice crisps for extra texture, while Chocolate Almond Crunch includes roasted almonds for an even nuttier bite.

These options are ideal for toast, pancakes, smoothies, fruit bowls, or simply enjoying by the spoonful.

If You're Looking for More Protein

Fitness enthusiasts often look for foods that help them increase their daily protein intake without sacrificing taste.

That's where the MyFitness Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter range comes in.

Available in Smooth, Crunchy, and Crispy formats, these variants contain up to 30g protein per 100g and include whey protein for an extra protein boost. They offer the familiar combination of chocolate and peanuts while helping support a higher-protein lifestyle.

For Younger Peanut Butter Fans

Why should the little ones miss out?

The MyFitness Junior range was created with younger consumers in mind.

Available in Smooth and Crunchy variants, these products combine premium roasted peanuts and chocolate with added vitamins and minerals. They provide protein while supporting everyday nutrition in a flavour kids enjoy and crave.

Happy Child, Happy Family!

So, Which One Should You Choose?

The answer depends entirely on your preference and lifestyle:

• Want a classic? Go Original.
  

• Prefer minimal ingredients? Choose Natural.
  

• Watching your sugar intake? Pick Zero Added Sugar.
  

• Love chocolate? There's an entire range for you.
  

• Looking for extra protein? Try our Dark Chocolate range.

The best peanut butter is the one you'll enjoy eating consistently.